Patent Attorneys & Engineers    

                  Patentics - Scientific patenting  

Patent4U Limited
P.O. Box 2162
87 Jabotinski St.
Petah Tikva 49120
Israel

ph: +972-3-9226767
fax: +972-3-9192287

Patentics™: Drawings comparison method

Function: Compare the invention in patents Figures
Use: Describe the invention in a drawing using text; readable by computer;
allows to compare inventions in drawings
Benefits: Compare drawings very fast, in a computer. For better applications
drafting, to present persuasive arguments during examination and in Court.

Details: We developed an efficient method for comparing drawings, and for indicating
differences therebetween. This may be especially important in comparing block
diagrams and flow charts, also in complex inventions, Internet and software.

The Figure illustrates an example of highlighting difference between two
drawings; crossed blocks 13E, 18E are missing in the second drawing
difference blocks 62E, 63E (preferably in another color) indicate blocks in
the second drawing which are missing in the first.
The final decision, as to the importance of these differences, is preferably
made by a human, an examiner or a patent agent, who understands the invention.

Patentics(TM) Patentics: Highlighting differences

  • Method for processing drawings

    a. Automatic: scan drawing, rotate to normal orientation
    pattern recognition of typical shapes: inputs, outputs; functions, blocks;
    or: in/out, processing, decision in flow chart
    pattern recognition of text in blocks

    b. Manual: manual finish, ensure correct shapes, text, direction of flow, in or out...

    c. extract distinguishing features, gist of it
    Rendering/Defining the above understanding of the invention in a standard,
    mathematic form - the Invention formula(TM), which can be easily used by other
    such Experts, and is also computer readable, to allow automatic processing of
    inventions. Such a formula may include for example a Connectivity list.
    Store the results.

    d. In one embodiment, the description is allowed to be ambiguous, it is not a
    complete and precise representation, but it gives the gist of the functional
    drawings so as to facilitate efficient comparison of drawings.
    It recognizes the fact that absolute precision is irrelevant, since the
    human rendering of inventions into drawings is also not precise.
    In another embodiment, predefined rules are used to achieve as complete and
    precise representation as possible.

    e. compare with text of the disclosure. Preferably, convert text to a standard
    vocabulary where necessary. Alternately, a local common vocabulary may be used,
    prepared to analyze just this patent/application or a group of similar patents.
    The vocabulary is used to translate relevant words and/or expressions in all
    cited references to the terms used in the examined patent or application.
    A common basis for text comparisons is required to perform meaningful
    comparisons.

    f. display common areas, points of difference.

    g. Allow for a human final decision - manual, an operator/ expert in patent law.

    Thus, methods/flow charts can be compared efficiently. Applications:
    * Patent searches of methods, software, systems using block diagrams,
    distributed computer systems (software and hardware)
    * Analyzing a complex patent or application, to improve it for example,
    or during examination at a Patent Office.

(C) Copyright 1995-2009 Patent4U Limited. All rights reserved. Patent4U and Patentics are trademarks and servicemarks of Patent4U Limited. By surfing this site you agree to the

terms and conditions.

The moral right of the authors has been asserted.

Patent4U Limited
P.O. Box 2162
87 Jabotinski St.
Petah Tikva 49120
Israel

ph: +972-3-9226767
fax: +972-3-9192287